Product flagged

Shirley May 1998

Product reviews

Type Product Card addedAugust 10 Threat lists flagged Reviews1
people’s rating
—
nobody has rated it yet. Yours will be the first.
5 0 4 0 3 0 2 0 1 0
Astrina AI 4.0

Counted separately and kept out of the people’s average — otherwise one machine score would read as the readers’ opinion.

Threat lists · flagged Product safety recall

Official safety regulators published alerts about a product of this kind.

The record is filed under the name, not under a barcode or a company number: it describes things of this kind, not necessarily the one in front of you.

Alerts on record1 HazardAccording to the list of ingredients, the product contains 2-(4-tert-butylbenzyl) propionaldehyde (BMHCA), which is prohibited in cosmetic products. BMHCA may harm the reproductive system, may harm the health of the unbo RiskSerious risk Country of originCzechia First alertNovember 21, 2025 Latest alertNovember 21, 2025 On our lists sinceAugust 10, 2026

What to do: Check the maker, the batch and the date of the exact item you have — the alert is about this kind of product.

Where this came from: EU Safety Gate / RAPEX (European Commission) — An official government safety register — product recalls and safety alerts.
Ratings by part Quality · Value for money — what we ask about this type
Quality Value for money

Nobody has rated the parts yet — the stars lead to the form, and a rating by parts adds up to the overall one.

Astrina Astrina AI Astrina AI rating 2026-09-19
Shirley May 1998 feels like a classic budget fragrance format: simple, direct, and aimed at people who want a recognizable scent without the ceremony of niche perfume. By our assessment, it usually wins on straightforward wearability and the old-school appeal of a named line that sounds familiar rather than experimental. The trade-off is clear enough: it is not trying to be layered or clever, so the finish can feel plain next to more polished modern scents. In practice that often means an easy spray-and-go bottle that does one job and gets out of the way. It sits closer to mainstream value fragrance than to anything collector-driven, with the usual emphasis on function over refinement. Shirley May 1998 makes sense for everyday use and for anyone who prefers a clean, uncomplicated scent, while people chasing complexity will probably find it thin.
Report

What is wrong with this review? A moderator reads every report.

We do not tell the author who reported them.
No live reviews here yet The first review from an account gets the green tick and sets the average for this listing. Write the first one
Have more to say? A full review with photos, video and YouTube clips — a separate page of your own. Write a full review
Write a review
Quality
Value for money

Photos and video can be attached from an account — Sign in

Guest reviews are published after moderation. Sign in to publish instantly.

What this page answers